ITDP India

Promoting sustainable and equitable transportation worldwide

  • Contact
  • Who We Are
    • Our Approach
    • ITDP India’s 2024
    • Contact Us
    • Career Opportunities
  • What We Do
    • Healthy Streets
    • Public Transport
    • Electric Mobility
    • Transit Oriented Development
    • Low Emission Zones
    • Inclusive Mobility
    • Traffic Reduction
  • Where We Work
    • NATIONAL
    • MAHARASHTRA
      • Pune
      • Pimpri Chinchwad
      • Nashik
    • TAMIL NADU
      • Chennai
      • Coimbatore
    • JHARKHAND
      • Ranchi
    • Agra
    • Ahmedabad
  • Blogs
  • Resources
  • National Challenges
    • India Cycles4Change Challenge
    • Streets for People Challenge
    • Transport4All Challenge
  • Urbanlogue
    • Urbanlogue Webinars – Series One
    • Urbanlogue Webinars – Series Two
    • Urbanlogue Webinars – Series Three
    • Urbanlogue Webinars – Series Four
  • Press

Pimpri Chinchwad’s Low Emission Zone Strategy Explained

30th April 2025 by admin


For centuries, the idea of running a mile (approximately 1.6km) in under four minutes seemed impossible. This milestone mocked human limits—until 1954, when Roger Bannister, an English athlete, redefined what’s possible. He cleverly broke down the mile into smaller segments, put in rigorous training, aced each sprint, and combined with an unshakable belief in his goal, eventually shattered the record with a three-minute, 59-second mile! Bannister’s feat didn’t just break records; it sparked a revolution, inspiring countless others to follow. Today, breaking the four-minute mile has become routine for elite runners.  

All it took was for someone to believe and champion the process. 

Now, let’s fast forward to the present. Can such an impossible belief — of restricting polluting vehicles across a city by creating Low Emission Zones (LEZs) – help change the way we work towards achieving cleaner air?  

You’ve likely heard the doubts: “How would we even start?” “Which vehicles should we restrict and where?” Yet, just like Bannister proved sceptics wrong, Pimpri Chinchwad is showing us that this too can be achieved by trusting the process. The city, since 2023, has been breaking down the challenge, taking it sprint by sprint, and proving that even ambitious goals for clean air are within reach through LEZs. In PCMC’s case, it is being done through the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP).  

Welcome to Pimpri Chinchwad’s inspiring LEZ journey, one step at a time, supported by ITDP India and International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT). These steps were developed collaboratively by both the teams in discussion with city officials, and we strive to learn and refine the process as we move forward. While there’s still a long way to go, the city’s commitment to walking this path shows that meaningful progress is possible with sustained effort.  

Step 1: Assessing Vehicle Inventory to Identify High-Polluting Vehicles 

Every city has vehicles plying on its streets but not many cities are aware of the characteristic of vehicle fleet that is in use, such as their age, engine types as per Bharat Stage (BS) standards, fuel type, number of kilometre they travel within the city, and other information.  The first step towards implementing LEZs is to know the above information through a primary survey or referring the recent vehicle emissions inventory reports.  

Action: Pimpri Chinchwad began its journey surveying about 4000 vehicles across all vehicle types at six petrol pumps and two parking lots, from September to October 2023.  

Image 1: Snapshots from the vehicle inventory survey

Outcome: The study revealed that about 70% are equipped with pre-BS, BS 1, BS 2, BS 3 & BS 4 engines, which are considerably more polluting than the Bharat Stage 6 standard – mandated in India since April 2020. Additionally, it highlighted that about 5% of heavy goods vehicles, light motor vehicles, heavy passenger vehicles and two wheelers are older than 15 years old—beyond the age deemed fit for use due to the release of excessive emissions. Upon further analysis, it was found that 85% of particulate matter (PM), nitrogen-di-oxide (NO2) emissions are coming from two wheelers, light motor vehicles, and goods vehicles. Such findings eventually informed the vehicle restriction strategy for the city’s LEZ. 

Image 2: Findings of the Vehicle- inventory survey. Nearly 70% of the vehicles were pre- BS 6

Image 3: Pollution load of different kinds of vehicles

Step 2: Identifying the Priority LEZ Areas to Restrict Vehicles  

Once the vehicle inventory is computed, the next step is to identify priority areas where vehicles can be restricted. These areas can gradually be expanded to form larger LEZs, with the potential for citywide implementation in the long term. 

Action: Pimpri Chinchwad, with support from ITDP India and ICCT, divided the city into a grid of two-km by two-km. Each of the four-km square areas were then evaluated through GIS mapping, against several criteria including existing pollution levels, population density, and street network density. Further, the presence of alternate modes of commuting such as public transport and improved walking and cycling infrastructure also made certain areas more suitable to initiate the implementation of LEZs. Grids with more schools and hospitals were prioritised to ensure that cleaner air was available for the vulnerable populations first. 

Outcome: After a detailed, data-driven GIS analysis, 15 grids were identified as potential LEZ areas in Pimpri Chinchwad. The shortlisted grids were further delineated into a boundary, based on the road network and other physical geographical factors. However, the city has now announced a city-wide LEZ, where highly polluting vehicles will be restricted across the city for greater impact. 

Image 4: Map of Pimpri Chinchwad with 15 potential grids where LEZs can be implemented.

Step 3: Defining the LEZ Goal and Estimating the Potential Impact on Air Quality 

The next step is to analyse the vehicle inventory data and assess the potential improvements in the city’s air quality from implementing the proposed LEZ in the prioritised area. 

Action: Pimpri Chinchwad conducted an in-depth analysis of the vehicle inventory survey data. Initially considering the scenario of restricting all pre-Bharat Stage 6 vehicles in priority area by 2026 with certain exceptions, the team developed forward-looking LEZ scenarios to evaluate the potential improvements in the city’s air quality if these restrictions are implemented. The analysis revealed that by 2026, if the city restricted vehicles which were pre-Bharat Stage 6 standards within the identified LEZ areas it could lead to a dramatic 80% – 90% reduction in PM2.5 emissions from vehicles. 

Image 5: Comparative analysis of how the city’s pollution levels will fare in different scenarios

Outcome: After carefully assessing the potential and impact of vehicle restrictions, the city is now setting its sights on introducing Environmental Protection Fees for highly polluting vehicles if they wish to enter or move in the city, instead of an outright ban. This game-changing move would ensure that fees are proportionate to the pollution each vehicle type generates, creating a powerful incentive for citizens to start making greener choices at the same time, boosting alternate modes of transport such as walking, cycling and public transport within Pimpri Chinchwad.  

Image 6: Various measures to be taken now and in the future by the city

Step 4: Conducting Stakeholder Discussions and Identifying Legal Pathways 

Large-scale initiatives like this require collaboration across stakeholders and the identification of legal pathways for successful implementation. It is pertinent to bring together all the relevant stakeholders and collate their input and ideas. 

Action: Pimpri Chinchwad began this process by engaging stakeholders from various departments of the Municipal Corporation, the RTO, and the Traffic Police. These discussions aimed to gather their insights, identify gaps, and explore tools and strategies for effective LEZ implementation.  

Outcome: This stakeholder engagement led to a pivotal breakthrough: the idea of integrating LEZs into the city’s existing institutional framework for combating air pollution – Pimpri Chinchwad’s Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP). This has provided the city with a legal instrument to swiftly activate Low Emission Zones when the air quality surpasses ‘moderate AQI’ (101-300). As per Pimpri Chinchwad’s GRAP, a highly polluting vehicle entering the LEZ area can only do so upon payment of an environment protection fee (EPF) ranging between Rs 100-750 depending on the category/type of vehicle. This applies to pre-BS-4 of goods vehicles, 2-wheelers, and personal cars. The Standing Committee approval was received in in September 2024. 

Step 5: Creating Enforcement Strategies for On-Ground Implementation 

Successful LEZ implementation requires a deep understanding of suitable enforcement technologies (including systems for collecting payments/fines) to identify violators and collection of EPF and establishing robust monitoring systems to measure vehicle tail-pipe emissions. The next step is to identify context-appropriate technologies and ensure their effective deployment. 

Action: Pimpri Chinchwad has been conducting expert roundtables and in-depth discussions to develop practical enforcement strategies and select suitable technologies for monitoring vehicle tail-pipe emissions.  

Outcome: After thorough deliberation and a detailed assessment of various enforcement and monitoring technologies, the city has decided to adopt Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) for enforcement, complemented by on-ground personnel. Efforts are now underway to procure and implement this advanced system, ensuring efficient and reliable monitoring on city streets. 

What’s next? 

As Pimpri Chinchwad progresses toward on-ground implementation of LEZs, with support from ITDP India and ICCT, the city will focus on key steps to implement the LEZ, including engaging with state government officials, traffic police, and technocrats to strengthen enforcement systems and policy reforms. The city will also identify complementary interventions, conduct stakeholder workshops and public consultations to gather feedback, and work towards officially notifying the LEZ. A communication plan and media engagement will ensure citizens understand the measures and support the transition towards clean air. 

Conclusion

The journey to establish LEZs in Pimpri Chinchwad is much like Roger Bannister’s historic four-minute mile—breaking down a seemingly impossible goal into achievable steps. Through meticulous data collection, strategic planning, and collaborative efforts, the city is in the process of paving the way toward cleaner, healthier air for its residents. While the road ahead is long, Pimpri Chinchwad is demonstrating that persistence and belief can turn ambitious goals into tangible realities. 

What’s even more inspiring is that, just as Bannister’s feat motivated countless others to push the boundaries of human endurance, Pimpri Chinchwad’s LEZ journey has the potential to ignite a movement across Indian cities. By encouraging cleaner vehicle technology, investing in walking, cycling, and public transport initiatives, and restricting polluting vehicles, Pimpri Chinchwad is setting an example of how ambitious steps can lead to cleaner air and healthier, more liveable cities. This journey could redefine what’s possible for cities across India, paving the way for a more sustainable future. Here’s a starting guide to all things LEZs.


Written by Aangi Shah, Senior Associate, ITDP India
With technical inputs from Siddhartha Godbole, Senior Associate, ITDP India
Edited by Donita Jose, Senior Associate, Communications, ITDP India

Filed Under: Low Emission Zones Tagged With: Air Pollution, ANPR, Electric bus, electric mobility, GNSS, Health crisis, India, London, Low Emission Zones, Maharashtra, Pimpri chinchwad, Public Transport, Pune, Sustainable Transport, Sustainable Transport Policy, Vehicular Pollution

Low emission zones: A roadmap to cleaner air in India

26th March 2025 by admin

As published in IDR Online


Air pollution has escalated from an environmental issue into a full-blown health crisis, impacting people of all ages. Its far-reaching effects are evident in the rising cases of respiratory disorders, chronic illnesses, and even increased mortality.  

In North India, stubble burning, especially during the cooler months, is often considered to be the leading cause of air pollution. However, data indicates that year-round vehicular emissions are a more significant contributor to air pollution than stubble burning, construction, or firecrackers. According to the Emissions Inventory (2020), vehicles accounted for 46 percent of total PM2.5 emissions—harmful to human health—in Pune as well. Vehicles were also the largest source of harmful gaseous pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (73 percent) and carbon monoxide (66 percent). Between 2012 and 2019, PM2.5 emissions from transport in Pune surged by 91 percent, driven by rapid vehicle growth and the widespread use of highly polluting vehicle models.

Cleaner vehicle technology is not enough

To reduce emissions from vehicle tailpipes, the central government introduced Bharat Stage (BS)-VI standards in 2020 for internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, which run on fuels such as petrol, diesel, and CNG. These standards set limits on pollutants that vehicles are allowed to emit per kilometre. At the same time, schemes such as FAME India, along with various state and city initiatives, actively promote the adoption of electric vehicles (EVs).

However, ICE vehicles currently outnumber EVs on the road, nullifying any gains in emissions reductions from the latter. What’s more, there continue to be far too many pre BS–VI vehicles in circulation to make any real dent in vehicular pollution. A case in point is a 2023 study conducted by Institute for Transportation and Development Policy (ITDP) India and International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT). The study found that approximately 70 percent of the vehicles plying in Pune and Pimpri-Chinchwad are pre-BS or BS-I to -IV, all of which are more polluting than BS-VI vehicles. Estimates show that one pre-BS car pollutes as much as 11 BS-VI cars, while one pre-BS truck pollutes as much as 14 BS-VI trucks.

To further complicate matters, a real-world vehicular emission study in Delhi and Gurugram revealed that BS-VI vehicles also exceed approved laboratory limits. Additionally, emission levels varied by vehicle type. For instance, BS-VI taxis and light goods vehicle fleets emitted 2.4 and 5 times more nitrogen oxides, respectively, compared to BS-VI cars used for personal purposes.

The long-standing mandate for Pollution Under Control (PUC) certification also falls short. The test is ineffective because it does not measure PM and nitrogen oxide emissions, testing only for carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and smoke. Furthermore, PUC assesses pollutants when the vehicle is stationary, not when it is in actual use. Hence, PUC certificates are not reliable indicators of a vehicle’s fitness with regard to its real-time driving emissions.

Low emission zones could be the answer

While encouraging cleaner vehicle technology is one part of the solution, there is also a need to simultaneously restrict the use of highly polluting vehicles.

Low emission zones (LEZs) are designated zones in a city where the use of polluting vehicles is restricted or discouraged. Such zoning aims to improve local air quality and health by reducing vehicle tailpipe emissions. Many cities—including London, Seoul, Paris, Lima, Brussels, and Beijing—have implemented LEZs. 

Cities typically make policies regarding which categories of polluting vehicles to restrict and where to impose these restrictions. Once an area is identified, signages and road markings are mounted to let drivers know that they are entering an LEZ. The rules are enforced by automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) cameras that read a vehicle’s number plate and identify whether it’s compliant or not. Cities like Paris mandate that every vehicle should have a sticker indicating their emission standard (Crit’Air sticker). In addition to these technologies, traditional traffic wardens visually identify violators as well.

But can LEZs be a silver bullet for vehicular pollution? Data from their implementation in London suggests they can in fact provide relief.

London’s LEZ—launched in 2008—now spans the Greater London Area, with approximately 1500 sq km demarcated as an Ultra Low Emission Zone (ULEZ). Its emissions standards are stringent and discourage the use of highly polluting or non-compliant vehicles by charging a heavy daily LEZ fee.

According to Transport for London’s six-month report published in July 2024, the ULEZ has helped reduce harmful roadside nitrogen dioxide (NO2) concentrations across the city. Over the years, the number of non-compliant vehicles driving within the LEZ has gone down as well. Now, a larger proportion of vehicles recorded in the LEZ are cleaner—96.2 percent, up from 39 percent in 2017. Further, a 2023 study by the University of Bath found that pollution reductions from the LEZ led to a 4.5 percent drop in long-term health problems and an 8 percent decline in respiratory issues.

At ITDP, we conducted a similar study in Pimpri-Chinchwad Municipal Corporation (PCMC) to determine the reduction in vehicular pollution as a result of restricting highly polluting vehicles in an LEZ and shifting users to the least polluting vehicles. Our study estimates that if the city government restricted pre-BS and BS-I to -IV vehicles in a designated LEZ and if vehicle users shifted to BS-VI vehicles instead, PM 2.5 emissions from vehicles could decrease by 80 percent by 2030.

Planning and implementing LEZs in India

LEZs are not new to India. Matheran, a holiday town in Maharashtra, restricts motor vehicle use to preserve clean air. Farther north, highly polluting vehicles are restricted around Taj Mahal to protect the monument from the corrosive effects of greenhouse gases. Delhi imposes an environment compensation (EC) charge on polluting trucks to discourage them from entering the city en route to neighbouring states, compelling them to take bypasses instead.

Over the last year and a half, ITDP India and ICCT have been supporting three cities in Maharashtra—Pimpri-Chinchwad, Pune, and Chhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar—in planning and implementing LEZs. The plan includes identifying highly polluting vehicle categories, defining LEZs, estimating benefits, and recommending complementary measures such as improving public transport connectivity and establishing enforcement systems.

In August 2024, the PCMC included LEZ in its Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP), a comprehensive strategy to reduce pollution across different sectors, including but not limited to vehicles. As per GRAP, the city will discourage the use of pre-BS and BS-I to -III private cars, two-wheelers, and light- and heavy-goods vehicles—which contribute approximately 90 percent of the total annual vehicular emissions—when the air quality falls to the moderate to poor category. The city will not ban such vehicles but will impose an Environment Protection Fee ranging from INR 100 to INR 750 daily for entry and movement inside the city.

LEZs must be accompanied with complementary measures like parking management, footpath, cycle tracks and public transport

However, translating policy into practice will require several key actions. Here are some of them:

1. Coordination between government departments

Implementation of LEZ measures will require the city government to set up robust enforcement mechanisms. For one, they will need to engage a variety of stakeholders, including the traffic police, Regional Transport Office (RTO) authorities, environmental agencies, and road departments, and establish seamless systems for coordination and communication. Additionally, the municipal corporation will need to deploy cost-effective and scalable IT-based solutions, such as ANPR cameras, to monitor and enforce rules, for which it will require dedicated funds.

But while city governments are responsible for designing and implementing LEZ frameworks, they often lack the legal authority, resources, or enforcement capacity needed for large-scale changes. State governments can provide the necessary legal frameworks, policy support, and regulatory backing to enable cities to effectively enforce these zones. It is equally important for the central government to be involved in drafting overarching policies, establishing national standards, and providing financial support to ensure that cities have the resources to implement the required infrastructure. The push towards transport electrification offers an example of such multi-tiered governance. The FAME-II policy, for instance, incentivises electric two- and three-wheelers (including e-rickshaws), commercial electric four-wheelers, and electric buses nationwide. At the state level, 21 Indian states have notified EV policies, with 15 offering direct incentives to EV buyers. These policies promote adoption through various consumer-facing incentives, such as purchase subsidies, exemptions from road tax and registration fees, reimbursements, and scrapping incentives.

2. Designing complementary infrastructure

Complementary infrastructure must be designed and funded to provide residents with viable, non-polluting alternatives to private vehicles. These include expanding public transport networks, widening or repaving footpaths, and installing charging stations for compliant vehicles. Barcelona’s Superblocks initiative is an example of an urban planning approach designed to reallocate public space from vehicular use. It reorganises traffic flow within a 3×3 grid of city blocks, prioritising pedestrians and community activities over vehicles. Within each superblock, traffic and non-residential parking are redirected to perimeter roads, significantly reducing vehicle movement inside. Streets within the superblocks are repurposed into pedestrian-centric spaces, with strict speed limits and an emphasis on accessibility. The reclaimed areas are enhanced with green spaces, bike lanes, playgrounds, and public seating, fostering a more vibrant and communal urban environment.

3. Garnering citizen support

Apprehensions about transitioning to cleaner vehicles are common in cities worldwide. For private EVs, the primary concern is the higher upfront cost, while for EV buses, resistance often stems from long procurement and waiting periods. Low-income groups and businesses are particularly impacted by the costs associated with this shift, which may lead to resistance against the policy. Delayed communication about the transition can exacerbate this issue. For instance, if potential buyers are unaware of upcoming restrictions on ICE vehicles, they might unknowingly invest a significant portion of their income in them, only to face policy changes later. This can create frustration and opposition to the transition.

Recognising this, many cities around the world announce such plans at least a year in advance, allowing residents and businesses to make informed choices. Paris, for example, supports small businesses in making the switch by offering financial incentives for cleaner alternatives. Brussels offers information on cleaner vehicle alternatives and financial assistance through its dedicated LEZ website. This website also features a mobility coach, a service that provides personalised advice on mobility options in the city.   

As India advances its efforts to combat air pollution and environmental degradation, LEZs can be a viable solution. By curbing vehicular emissions, these zones can play a crucial role in improving air quality, easing congestion, and reclaiming urban spaces for healthier, more liveable cities. However, their success depends on integrating them within a multi-pronged strategy that includes strengthening public transport, enhancing pedestrian infrastructure, and supporting a just transition for affected communities. LEZs can serve as a starting point for reimagining India’s cities—where clean air is a right and sustainable mobility the norm, with urban spaces that prioritise people over pollution.


Written by Parin Visariya, Deputy Manager at ITDP India

Filed Under: Low Emission Zones Tagged With: Air Pollution, ANPR, Delhi, Electric bus, electric mobility, GNSS, Health crisis, India, London, Low Emission Zones, Maharashtra, Pimpri chinchwad, Public Transport, Pune, Sustainable Transport, Sustainable Transport Policy, Vehicular Pollution

Low Emission Zones: Breathing Life into Chennai’s Future

6th February 2025 by admin

As appeared in the The New Indian Express


Chennai – from the bustling markets of T Nagar to the IT parks in OMR, is a city constantly on the move. But with every step forward, we seem to drag the weight of traffic and pollution along with us. Every day, hundreds of thousands of vehicles clog its arteries, choking the city with pollution, noise and traffic. Chennai’s roads see an addition of nearly 1.5 lakh vehicles every year. The result? Some days, the air we breathe in Chennai feels like smoking almost nine cigarettes every day. But what if we could create spaces where the air feels lighter, the roads free of traffic, and the sky a little clearer? One piece to this puzzle might lie in the concept that cities around the world, including some in India, are experimenting with – Low Emission Zones (LEZ), also often known as Clean Air Zones.
These zones typically limit highly polluting vehicles by either charging non-compliant ones or restricting the worst polluters, with penalties for violators. International cities like London, Milan, Seoul, Paris, Lima, and Beijing, have already embraced LEZs and Indian cities are not far behind

India’s LEZ Experiment: Hope on the Horizon

India is already exploring strategies to reduce urban pollution. Delhi’s Environment Compensation Charge (ECC) on commercial vehicles, Agra’s Zero Emission Zones (ZEZs) around the Taj Mahal, and Kevadiya’s restrictions on non-electric vehicles demonstrate proactive steps. Matheran banned all motor vehicles
to protect its ecosystem, while pedestrian zones (not classified as LEZs) in Delhi’s Chandni Chowk and Bengaluru’s Church Street show air quality improvements. Further, cities like Pune, Pimpri Chinchwad, and Chhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar are trialling LEZs, prioritising area-wide interventions.

Why LEZs matter for Chennai

Staggering numbers on the Air Quality Index from cities like Delhi often overshadow narratives and make headlines, creating an impression that cities like Chennai do not have pressing air quality concerns. According to the Urban Emissions Report 2021, Chennai ranked among the top 10 cities in India with the worst air quality. Our everyday commute, especially through heavy traffic hotspots like T Nagar, Anna Salai, Kathipara junction, or Poonamallee High Road is not just stressful—it’s hazardous to our health, with exposure to dangerous levels of particulate matter (PM) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2). Imagine the impact a LEZ could have in this situation. London’s ULEZ, launched in 2019, reduced nitrogen dioxide by 44% and traffic by 30%, with a 21% increase in cycling. Barcelona’s LEZ cut traffic by 30%, NO2 levels by 24%, and increased cycling by 15%. Santiago’s LEZ reduced central traffic by 20%, with particulate matter and NO2 levels dropping by 40% in some areas. What if Chennai could experience a similar transformation?

Encouragingly, Tamil Nadu’s State Planning Commission, in collaboration with the British Deputy High Commission, Chennai, recently came out with a report on Low Emission Zoning – A Toolkit for Chennai. It integrates best practices from the UK with a customised roadmap for Chennai, balancing community engagement with the city’s unique priorities and the complexities of rapid urbanisation.

This report further states that LEZs in Chennai could cut NO2 and PM2.5 levels by over 20%, significantly improving public health. LEZs go beyond cleaner air—they improve street efficiency by cutting congestion, especially during peak hours, making commutes more reliable and fast. Fewer vehicles also mean fewer accidents, a problem that Chennai’s packed roads know all too well. They also offer cities a chance to step-up and enhance streets for walking and cycling.

For LEZs to truly succeed, the city will also need reliable and improved public transport services. Collaborations with the Metropolitan Transport Corporation (Chennai) Ltd (MTC) and the Chennai Metro Rail Limited (CMRL) are crucial to ensure that these zones are supported with high-quality and high-frequency services to encourage people to choose sustainable and affordable alternatives while reducing resistance to these zones. By using enforcement mechanisms, whether through priced or non-priced LEZs, implementing these zones in Chennai would support the state-wide goals to boost the adoption of electric vehicles as outlined in its EV Policy. The change doesn’t have to happen overnight, but with the right policies and action, it could be gradually phased in.

A Roadmap for Chennai  

Turning this vision into reality requires a clear roadmap.

1. Designing the Zones with Data:  

LEZs must be backed by data-driven insights. Use vehicle emission surveys across the city, air quality sensors and real-time traffic data to identify the most polluted and congested zones to deliver visible improvements. Clear policies and regulations: State and city level administrators should leverage the recent Low Emission Zoning Toolkit, to create clear policies that enable enforceable measures and plans.

2. Engaging People:

Involving communities and creating champions amongst health care professionals and local community leaders and others to support the cause is important.

3. Political Will

In addition to frameworks and policies, LEZs need elected officials to champion implementation. They must align stakeholders and ensure these ideas are prioritised in budgets and planning.

4. Phased Rollout

Begin by implementing Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) around areas like hospitals and schools.
As the improvements register in public consciousness, gradually, these zones can be expanded over a period of time, while encouraging the use of non-motorised mobility and making public transport more efficient

5. Measure Impact for Scale- Up

Track key metrics like air quality improvements, traffic reduction, and public transport adoption to evaluate success and expand programme.

LEZs offer a powerful, practical way to clear the air—figuratively and literally.
Let’s give Chennai the fresh breath it deserves.


Written by

Aswathy Dilip, Managing Director ITDP India, South Asia Director, Institute for Transportation and Development Policy

Sanjiv Gopal, Chief Strategy Officer, Asar

Filed Under: Low Emission Zones Tagged With: Air Pollution, ANPR, Chennai, Delhi, Electric bus, electric mobility, GNSS, Health crisis, India, London, Low Emission Zones, Public Transport, Sustainable Transport, Sustainable Transport Policy, Vehicular Pollution

10 Impactful Solutions to Improve India’s Air Quality

10th December 2024 by admin


Air pollution in India has reached a tipping point, threatening the health and well-being of millions. Amid this growing crisis, one promising solution is the implementation of Low Emission Zones (LEZs)—designated areas where polluting vehicles are restricted to curb emissions and improve air quality. To help cities across India tackle this issue, ITDP India recently launched Low Emission Zone Basics, a comprehensive guide for creating cleaner, healthier urban environments. 

At the launch, experts from global organisations shared crucial insights on how LEZs can play a pivotal role in addressing air pollution, while also offering policy recommendations to guide India’s path to cleaner air. From improving data collection to enhancing public transport and promoting localised climate action, these strategies provide a roadmap for urgent and effective change. Read on for key takeaways from the experts who are shaping the future of India’s air quality. 

The experts include, Shashi Verma, Chief Technology Officer, Transport for London (TfL); Dr. Anju Goel, Associate Director at The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI); Parin Visariya, Deputy Manager at ITDP India; Dr. Sandra Wappelhorst, Senior Researcher at The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT), Berlin;  Sree Kumar Kumaraswamy, Program Director at World Resources Institute (WRI); and Dr. Vivek Vaidyanathan, Program Manager at Artha Global. 

1. Better research on sources of air pollution

Central government must invest in better collection and dissemination of data and research on the sources of pollution. To date, the public debate around pollution in India is clouded in fog with some suggesting it is because of Diwali and some suggesting is because of crop burning, which is fundamentally not true. Air pollution in Gangetic plains is far more complex and getting better evidence is something central government can work on – Shashi Verma, Chief Technology Officer, Transport for London (TfL)    

2. Need for multiple interventions

London’s air quality success stems from a series of cumulative interventions since the 1950s, starting with banning coal burning, introducing clean diesel programmes, and expanding LEZs. A major contributor to improvement was increasing the mode share of sustainable transport, which reduced overall vehicle numbers. The broader lesson is to have a comprehensive approach in addressing multiple sources of pollution. – Shashi Verma, Chief Technology Officer, Transport for London (TfL) 

3. State government must approve LEZs 

Pimpri Chinchwad, in Maharashtra has decided to implement an Environmental Protection Charge ranging from ₹100-750, for polluting vehicles entering the LEZs. But the enforcement of this requires collaboration with the Road Transport Officials (RTOs) and traffic departments. Currently, there is no provision within the transport department to address such violations, making the need for an enforcement mechanism essential. State-level approvals and notifications are also necessary to formally designate the area as a LEZ. State governments must play a supportive role by bringing all stakeholders together to develop a clear, actionable plan. – Parin Visariya, Deputy Manager at ITDP India 

4. Improve public transport

Public transport connectivity in most cities remains inadequate and requires significant upgrades. State support is crucial to ensure there is an increase in the number of buses and improvement in the overall network. – Parin Visariya, Deputy Manager at ITDP India

5. Package LEZs for health

One way to get faster acceptance of concepts like LEZs is to make the stakeholders focus on how it will improve health. Talking about its benefits in sensitive areas in terms of schools, places of worship, hospitals, works well in convincing city authorities to take this up. – Dr. Vivek Vaidyanathan, Program Manager at Artha Global 

6. Focus on funding clean air in rural areas

Currently the National Clean Air Programme funds go only to urban local bodies, where the concerns are more about road dust, vehicular emissions etc. But when it comes to rural areas, these funds are not applicable. Here the sources of pollution are also different like biomass burning. This is when state governments need to pitch in. Having only NCAP as a funding source won’t solve the problem. We need various other state level schemes.  – Dr. Anju Goel, Associate Director at The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) 

7. Budget for climate at municipality levels

Cities must explore ways to tap into their existing municipal budget to start climate works. If all departments commit some amount to climate, it can be a starting point with no need to look outside for funds. For instance, in most municipalities, the roads budget is the highest- so it can be leveraged to implement action to create clean air. – Sree Kumar Kumaraswamy, Program Director at World Resources Institute (WRI) 

8. Develop state-level schemes

States must come up with innovative mechanisms like the Majhi Vasundhara initiative in Maharashtra where the state has decentralised climate action. Now be it a village or a city, through their own means, they can take up small ticket projects that work towards climate action. This kind of model of sourcing innovation from the ground up is an excellent example and state can play a facilitating role to enable thinking innovatively. – Sree Kumar Kumaraswamy, Program Director at World Resources Institute (WRI) 

9. Focus on creating a good narrative

Create a phased and gradual LEZ plan with clear timelines to allow citizens and businesses to have time to adapt. Offer financial assistance to low-income groups and small businesses to transition to compliant vehicles. Develop mobility programs like air bonuses to encourage alternatives to car ownership. Speak to all stakeholders and communicate the programme. – Dr. Sandra Wappelhorst, Senior Researcher at The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT), Berlin 

10. Start with CPCBs and non-attainment cities

When working with state governments, the Central Pollution Control Board is a good entry point, wherein they can enact some of the state-wide regulations and laws that’s applicable to all non-attainment cities. – Dr. Vivek Vaidyanathan, Program Manager at Artha Global

Low Emission Zone Basics


Written by Donita Jose, Senior Associate, Communications and Development, ITDP India

Filed Under: Low Emission Zones Tagged With: Air Pollution, ANPR, Delhi, Electric bus, electric mobility, GNSS, Health crisis, India, London, Low Emission Zones, Maharashtra, Pimpri chinchwad, Public Transport, Pune, Sustainable Transport, Sustainable Transport Policy, Vehicular Pollution

Three Things Indian Cities Need to do Now to Start the Fight Against Vehicular Pollution 

4th November 2024 by admin


“Winter is coming”—a phrase made famous by the sitcom series Game of Thrones—has found an eerie resonance in India. Much like how the people of Winterfell dreaded the arrival of winter and the mythical evil creatures- the White Walkers, in India, it is not a creature, but the polluted air itself, that is dreaded.  

Though it’s barely November, a thick layer of pollutants is already blanketing the skies, and all eyes are searching for the culprits. Is it construction waste, crackers, or crop burning? However, one source, which remains largely overlooked, and often slides through the cracks, while continuing to remain the biggest challenge- is vehicular pollution. A recent study by the Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology confirms this. Conducted in the month of October 2024, the study revealed that stubble burning contributed only 1-2% of Delhi’s total air pollution in the month, while vehicular emissions accounted for a significant 11.2% – 14.2%. This makes vehicle emissions the single biggest identifiable, yet silent contributor to poor air quality, which affects the Indian cities not just in winter but year-round—making it the most urgent problem to address. 

Infact, studies being released year after year all indicate how rapidly the situation is deteriorating. The latest report reiterating this, is the Greenpeace report, which spotlights the alarming situation in South Indian cities specifically, which conventionally were believed to have cleaner air. The data from this report suggests the PM2.5 level in these cities is also no better for living standards, with a few like Hyderabad, Chennai, and Visakhapatnam, seeing levels up to 9- 10 times higher than WHO standard. As explained above, a significant part of these rising pollution levels is contributed by the growing population of vehicles.  

While the sustainable transport sector has long advocated for walking, cycling, public transport, and clean vehicle technology as solutions, it is clear that combating vehicular pollution requires a multifaceted approach beyond that. This blog outlines three key Mantras (strategies) that cities can adopt right now to tackle this growing menace. Some of these have already been implemented/ in the process of implementation in our lighthouse city, Pimpri Chinchwad, which stands as a good example for many other growing Indian cities. 

1. Shift to sustainable modes such as walking, cycling, and public transport  

First, cities should focus on creating not just isolated stretches but comprehensive networks of footpaths and cycle tracks. A well-connected network makes sustainable transport options more convenient and accessible, encouraging people to shift to these modes.  

However, providing just infrastructure may not be enough in most cases. Cities must invest in raising awareness through campaigns to nudge behavior change. Policies and legislative reforms are also crucial to embedding these practices into the city’s fabric. 

What’s a good model to emulate? Many global cities, such as Singapore, have initiated the concept of 15-minute cities. Some Indian Cities have had the chance to adopt this concept, leveraging existing initiatives like the Harit Setu project in Pimpri Chinchwad, which aims to enhance walking and cycling infrastructure in the city. Here, the plan is to make a localised network of connected footpaths and cycling tracks within smaller neighbourhoods, across the city so that people can simply opt to walk or cycle for short distances. Through such interventions, they also get sustainable options for last- mile connectivity. 

A glimpse of Linear Garden street, one of the ideal streets in PCMC which prioritises pedestrians and cyclists

However, while walking and cycling provide a sustainable alternative for short trips, they alone will not reduce congestion or pollution. For longer trips, more and better buses which connect the many networks of roads are the need of the hour to alleviate pollution and congestion. Moreover, improving bus services, including their frequency, reliability, and coverage, is crucial. Buses should seamlessly integrate with other transport modes, such as metro systems, footpaths, and cycle tracks, creating a comprehensive and efficient transport network. This interconnectedness enables commuters to make longer journeys more conveniently, thus making public transport a more attractive option. 

While these suggestions might shift a chunk of road users to sustainable modes, there will still be a section who would opt to use personal/private vehicles for travel because of its convenience. To address the emission concerns for that segment, incentivising cleaner vehicles will be an option.  

2. Incentivise people to use cleaner vehicles

Alongside promoting sustainable modes of transport, cities need to encourage the use of cleaner vehicles. This can be done in three ways: transitioning to cleaner technologies, scrapping older polluting vehicles, and building robust electric vehicle (EV) infrastructure. 

India has already taken a step in this direction by adopting Bharat Stage-VI (BS-VI) emission standards, which significantly reduce emissions from new vehicles. However, cities can push this further by promoting electric vehicles (EVs). Local governments should implement strong scrappage policies that incentivise owners of older, polluting vehicles to retire and scrap them in exchange for financial benefits or rebates on EVs.  

Cities also need to upscale their EV infrastructure, particularly by setting up widespread charging stations. A comprehensive EV Readiness Plan can guide cities in developing this infrastructure and ensuring that the transition to EVs is smooth and well-supported. 

For example, Pimpri Chinchwad’s Electric Vehicle Readiness Plan 2023 outlines some of these, by setting a goal of having 30% of the new vehicle registrations in city shift to EV by 2026.  They are doing so by establishing 100 EV charging stations and offering incentives for e-auto drivers. Property tax rebates are also being offered to those setting up charging point in their properties. Furthermore, the PCMC’s and Pune’s shared bus service, Pune Mahanagar Parivahan Mahamandal Ltd (PMPML), already operates 473 e-buses—India’s third-largest fleet—and is continuing to expand its fleet. These efforts – both on the front improved vehicle technology and on the front of emission reduction through improved public transport, not only reduce emissions but also set the stage for a future where EVs become the primary mode of motorised transport. 

Cities infact can go a step further, to effectively promote the use of cleaner vehicles. They can go for a dual approach of simultaneously making it more challenging to rely on personal vehicles.  

An electric bus from PMPML fleet

3. Discourage the use of personal vehicles through pricing parking and LEZs 

Cities must make it harder for people to rely on private vehicles, especially older, polluting models. Two effective ways to achieve this are by pricing parking and establishing Low Emission Zones (LEZs). 

Proper parking management can reduce the number of vehicles on the road by making it expensive to park in public spaces. When parking fees are levied, people think twice before using their cars, potentially avoiding the trip, opting for shorter trips, using public transport or finding other alternative solutions instead. This approach not only discourages unnecessary vehicle use but also frees up critical street space for creating vibrant public spaces on street. When authorised designated spots are demarcated by the city on the streets, it further reduces the time and fuel wasted in searching for a parking spot.  

Effective parking management can deter vehicle use, while LEZs take it a step further by restricting the most polluting vehicles from entering key areas. Together, they provide a strong mechanism to reduce vehicular emissions. 

In an LEZ, only vehicles with low or zero emissions—such as electric vehicles or those that meet the recommended emission standards (BS-VI)—are allowed to enter. LEZs can be city-wide or focused on strategically selected areas, making them an effective tool for cutting emissions in densely populated regions. 

For instance, in cities like London there has been a drastic reduction. As per the Mayor’s report, London’s Ultra Low Emission Zone (ULEZ), launched in 2019, has led to a 44% reduction in nitrogen dioxide levels and a roughly 30% decrease in traffic in central areas, alongside a 21% increase in cycling. 

In India, a study by ITDP India and ICCT in Pimpri Chinchwad found that restricting pre-BS-VI vehicles in a designated LEZ could reduce PM 2.5 emissions by up to 91% within a year (if all the pre-BS-VI users switch to EVs). Without such measures, pollution levels will decrease by only 50% in the next five years, under current practices (which involves the expected business as usual gradual natural transition to BS-VI). 

Designated parking spaces created on a street in PCMC

While these three Mantras provide a holistic approach to combat vehicular emissions, acknowledging the issue is the first step.  We urge cities and policymakers not to let air pollution caused by vehicles fade into the background or be treated as a seasonal issue. Addressing vehicular emissions requires year-round effort—mode shift, cleaner vehicle technologies, and Low Emission Zones must work in tandem to tackle pollution from all angles. 


Written by Donita Jose, Senior Associate, Communications and Development, ITDP India

With technical inputs from Parin Visariya, Deputy Manager at ITDP India

Filed Under: Low Emission Zones Tagged With: Air Pollution, ANPR, Delhi, Electric bus, electric mobility, GNSS, Health crisis, India, London, Low Emission Zones, Maharashtra, Pimpri chinchwad, Public Transport, Pune, Sustainable Transport, Sustainable Transport Policy, Vehicular Pollution

Answers to Some Common Questions About Low Emission Zones

26th September 2024 by admin

With the idea of Low Emission Zones (LEZs) gaining steam in India, here are a few concepts on the Legal, Institutional, and Technological aspects of vehicular emission.


A recap of Urbanlogue 4.0 Episode 2

LEZs are the need of the hour to arrest the invisible yet harmful impact of vehicular pollution. However, the entire subject can be challenging to grasp. Alongside figuring out the enforcement technology and monitoring, in India, data quality and impacts on marginalised communities add to the complexity. 

On September 18, ITDP India and ICCT hosted a webinar featuring six experts, moderated by Amit Bhatt, India Managing Director, ICCT, wherein they unwrapped these concepts by sharing their journeys from managing air/vehicular pollution in cities like Delhi, Pimpri Chinchwad, and Surat, alongside insights from Brussels and Seoul. You can watch the full webinar here. 

Here are seven frequently asked questions around Low Emission Zones, which were answered during  the webinar. 

1. What are the technologies available to enforce Low Emission Zones and which is best suited for Indian context? 

Parin Visariya, Deputy Manager at ITDP India, highlighted two key enforcement methods for India: Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) and Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS). 

“What’s currently feasible in India is ANPR, which uses cameras to read vehicle number plates and deduct fees for entering Low Emission Zones,” Visariya explained. GNSS, an alternative, connects to an on-board unit inside the vehicle via a cellular network to charge fees, though the unit costs INR 8,000-10,000. 

Srinivas Ganji, Solution Delivery Director (Urban Transport), Arcadis, discussed the challenges of both. ANPR faces issues like low visibility due to weather, traffic congestion, and low-light conditions. However, due to improved algorithms and infrared cameras, the efficacy of ANPR system is close to 90%.  

Regarding GNSS, Ganji pointed out a few concerns. “A lot of incentives will have to be given to maintain the onboard unit. Privacy is also a concern as all movements can be tracked and it’s still a question on who will bear the charges of transmission of the data.”  

2. Are our vehicle emissions measuring methods robust enough? 

Vaibhav Kush, Researcher at ICCT, highlighted the importance of accurately monitoring emissions for implementing LEZs. Currently, India measures pollution at two stages: during vehicle prototype testing before the production and through Pollution Under Control (PUC) checks. However, these methods only reflect emissions under controlled conditions, either in labs or when vehicles are stationary. Neither show actual pollution levels emitted. Factors like load, maintenance, driving habits, road surface, traffic congestion impact emissions. 

ICCT’s 2022 study in Delhi using the roadside sensors revealed a significant gap between tested and real-world emissions.   

3. What are the various legal routes to implement LEZs  

Vaibhav Kush, further elaborated on the legal routes to establish LEZs. He explained that LEZs require legal backing for notifying the LEZ area, restricting polluting vehicle type, imposing fines and more. There are legal provisions available at national, state and city level. It depends on which government is initiating it. Vaibhav highlighted the cases of vehicle restrictions implemented in Delhi, Taj Trapezium Zone in Agra, Kevadia in Gujarat. He also highlighted a case where judiciary (Supreme Court) ordered the Delhi government to levy the environment compensation charge. 

He highlighted that the Air Act of 1981, Central Motor Vehicle Act of 1988 and state laws like Maharashtra Municipal Corporation Act 1949, can enable LEZ implementation. 

4. How robust should the city’s pollution monitoring network be? 

Ronak Sutaria, Founder and CEO, and Kevin Joshi, Product Engineer and Researcher, from Respirer Living Sciences, emphasised the need for robust and dense pollution monitoring networks to implement LEZs. For Surat Municipal Corporation (SMC), they deployed low-cost monitoring machines to measure PM 2.5 and 10 across 20 locations, focusing on densely populated areas. The data was shared with SMC and revealed nuanced results—PM 2.5 levels spiked during morning rush hours at certain junctions, while industrial areas peaked in the evening, and commercial zones showed higher levels during weekends. Regular analysis enabled tailored decisions and actions. 

“We need data analytics specialists, to help city corporations make informed decisions,” Joshi stated. 

On data accuracy, Ronak also highlighted that it is important to understand the purpose of using the data. Based on technologies and their cost, data accuracy can vary between 70%-90%.  

5. Is crowdsourcing of pollution data the way ahead for monitoring and predicting pollution levels in micro levels? 

Dr Suraj Ghosh, Associate Counsellor from CII- ITC Centre of Excellence for Sustainable Development, shared that their pollution monitoring and forecasting model was built on crowdsourced data. Their new model integrates emission inventories, meteorological data, live traffic, ambient air quality, and sensor data. By applying the Chemical Transport Model, they can predict pollutant levels for the next 72 hours, which aids measures like the Graded Response Action Plans. 

Their model achieves a resolution of 1 km x 1 km down to zone and ward levels, with the potential to enhance accuracy to 200 meters, though data quality remains a concern. “To improve accuracy of forecasts, we need good data,” he shared. 

6. What can cities in India learn from international cities like Brussels, Seoul, and London? 

Anindita Ghosh, Senior Researcher, UITP, shared several insights from different cities’ LEZ experiences. In Brussels, citizens were proactive in pushing the government to implement LEZs. In Seoul, LEZs were introduced only in the Business Zone, a model that could work in India as well. 

In all these cities, including London, effective communication played a vital role. “Engaging citizens consistently is key. Making them part of the process is essential,” Ghosh said. Various tools such as leaflets, videos, and advertisements were used extensively, with communication beginning 2-3 years before implementation. Efforts were also made to include marginalised communities, a practice that should be adopted in India. 

7. How can we address equity issues on marginalised communities while implementing LEZ? 

Globally, cities have provided incentives to encourage the transition to cleaner vehicles. Cities have provided free public transport passes for two years. Financial incentives are priortised for e-cycles and small freight vehicles for businesses, subject to polluting vehicles being scrapped. Incentives for personal cars are avoided to reduce congestion. All cities invest heavily in improving public transport, walking and cycling infrastructure. Indian cities, similarly, must priortise to improve public transport (especially bus transport) and offer target incentives after analysing the budget. 

Watch this space for more on Low Emission Zones! Join our Whatsapp group now for more webinars and talks!


Team Urbanlogue 


Written by Donita Jose, Senior Associate, Communications and Development, ITDP India

With technical inputs from Parin Visariya, Deputy Manager at ITDP India

Filed Under: Low Emission Zones Tagged With: Air Pollution, ANPR, Delhi, Electric bus, electric mobility, GNSS, Health crisis, India, London, Low Emission Zones, Maharashtra, Pimpri chinchwad, Public Transport, Pune, Sustainable Transport, Sustainable Transport Policy, Vehicular Pollution

  • Who We Are
    • Our Team
    • Contact Us
    • Opportunities
    • Our Approach
  • What We Do
    • Complete Streets and Parking Management
    • Public Transport
    • Transit Oriented Development
    • Inclusive Mobility
  • Where We Work
    • Agra
    • Ahmedabad
    • MAHARASHTRA
    • Pune – Pimpri-Chinchwad
    • Nashik
    • TAMIL NADU
    • Chennai
    • Coimbatore
    • JHARKHAND
    • Ranchi
    • NATIONAL
  • News
  • Resources
  • Get Involved
    • Donate

Copyright © 2025 · ITDP Responsive on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

 

Loading Comments...