Summary: Waiting for a bus feels much longer when you don’t know when it will arrive because the psychology of waiting means a wait is judged less by the actual minutes and more by how much certainty and control, we have. ITDP and GIZ India’s Reaching Your Riders – Investigated survey of 1,700 commuters across eight cities found that about 33% use websites or apps to get information on bus routes or schedules. But having an app doesn’t guarantee real-time information: only 42% of commuters got real-time updates from apps, and many times the bus arrival time was inaccurate. If a rider did not have access to digital information, the next best alternative was information at bus-stops or simply asking the staff, but most bus stops lacked even basic schedules, let alone live displays. This is partly because transit agencies run the buses while Urban Local Bodies manage the stops, which leaves gaps in coordination. The blog also draws on a 2018 Transport for London study, which found that real-time information nearly halved the frustration of waiting.
All of us have experienced that uneasy feeling of waiting, whether it be waiting for exam results, waiting for a response to an important WhatsApp message, waiting to hear back on that promotion. Or simply, waiting for a bus. What makes waiting difficult is not the wait itself but not knowing how long you would continue waiting for; not knowing when the bus will arrive or if it will show up at all. In a world where you can track your food delivery driver making three mysterious stops before reaching your house, not knowing where your bus is can feel particularly frustrating.
The frustration doesn’t come from the actual wait time, but from the perceived one: the psychology of waiting. Most of us can handle a five-minute wait for a bus without breaking a sweat but if no one tells us that the bus is just five minutes away, those same five minutes start feeling more like 15. And that is when, for most commuters, a ride-hailing apps or a passing auto-rickshaw suddenly start looking very attractive. This is why all commuters should have access to accurate, real-time information on buses.
How easy is it for an Indian bus user to get real time information on bus arrivals?
To explore this further, earlier this year, GIZ India and ITDP conducted a study, called Reaching Your Riders – Investigated, under the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) SUM-ACA project. A sample group of 1700 bus commuters across eight cities in India (Bengaluru, Delhi, Chennai, Pune, Hyderabad, Kochi, Bhubaneswar, Surat) were surveyed to understand their perceptions of their local bus service, with a particular focus on how they access information from that agency.
Across all eight cities, websites and mobile apps provided by the bus service were among the most commonly used channels for accessing bus route and schedule information, with an average of 33% of commuters relying on these platforms. This highlights a strong shift towards mobile-first communication. In Bengaluru and Chennai, this number was close to 44% in both the cities, and in Delhi it was as high as 50%.

Figure 01: How commuters across the eight cities get information about bus routes and scheduling to plan your journey
However, just because people use apps doesn’t mean they are getting real-time information. For real-time information, 42% relied on apps, 10% on Google Maps, and 16% on bus-stop displays. That leaves a striking 32% with no real-time information at all. Nearly one in three riders was travelling blind, with no idea when their bus would arrive.

Figure 02: How commuters across the eight cities get real-time information of their bus
What we also observed that while the apps have ‘live tracking’ of buses, it is sometimes inaccurate or delayed. This matters because it changes how waiting feels. Even if they have an app in hand, they were possibly looking at a scheduled time of arrival, and not at the real-time expected time of arrival.
A wait with a trustworthy countdown is a wait you can plan around: have that quick cup of coffee, make a call, or leave the house two minutes later. But a wait with an unreliable number or no number at all, makes the service feel less reliable.
How do ‘offline’ bus users in India know about bus arrivals?
What the data also told us is that there is a clear split in how commuters access information. While a large portion rely on digital channels, the other half still depend on offline sources when digital access is unavailable. For example, in Pune, about 40% of respondents use the Aapli PMPML app, but a significant 35% still turn to bus stop signages and bus staff for updates. Across most cities, after apps, these human and physical touchpoints remain the most trusted and immediate sources of information, according to the study.
But the catch is that when we looked at bus stops across these eight cities, we found that not all have information on routes and schedules let alone real-time LED display boards. In other words, the “information point” is still sometimes just a hopeful pole with a timetable (if at all) and a lot of guesswork. In some cities like Chennai, real-time displays are being introduced, but issues around maintenance and accuracy are cropping up. So, while the technology is on its way in, the reliability hasn’t quite made the journey yet.
One critical issue is that in most cities, while the bus agencies have complete control over their fleet and operations, bus stops are maintained by the Urban Local Bodies (ULBs). This kind of fragmentation is not helpful when modernising the system because it splits responsibility across multiple agencies that don’t always work in sync. As a result, improvements tend to happen in parts rather than as a unified system. A city might invest in better buses or digital tracking, but the physical infrastructure at bus stops may not match up or vice versa.
Solutions such as accurate mobile apps, real-time display boards at bus stops, or well-trained staff are no longer optional—they are essential. They can significantly shape how commuters experience their bus journey.
What Indian transit bus agencies can learn from this London study on tackling uncertain bus wait times?
A 2018 study on Transport for London (TfL) found that by just providing real-time bus arrival information can significantly improve a passenger’s waiting experience. They used a ‘waiting time multiplier’, which compared how onerous waiting feels in relation to time spent travelling on the bus. For passengers who did not check real-time information, the multiplier was 2.53, meaning one minute of waiting felt like spending almost 2.5 minutes. This reduced to 2.03 for mobile phone users, 1.23 for internet users, and 1.09 for those using both channels. Basically, passengers who had access to reliable bus arrival information via phone and internet viewed waiting as much less frustrating than those who did not.
This may seem like a small difference, but it represents a meaningful psychological improvement. The actual waiting time had not changed; what changed was passengers’ sense of certainty and control. The study showed that providing timely, reliable information can soften the negative experience of waiting, making public bus transport feel more convenient and dependable even when service levels remain the same.
The lesson for us is simple: people will not abandon the bus because they cannot wait for five minutes; but they may do so if they do not know whether they are waiting for five minutes or fifteen. In the psychology of waiting, that difference matters. Thus, while our cities invest in better buses, better infrastructure, and modern digital system, timely and reliable information must be a core part of the service and not an afterthought. This information doesn’t magically reduce waiting time, but it certainly will reduce wondering time; only then, our riders are more likely to wait, trust the system, and choose the bus again.
Written by Kashmira Dubash, Deputy Director, ITDP India
Frequently Asked Questions
- How do most Indian bus commuters get information on bus routes and schedules?
According to the GIZ India and ITDP’s survey of eight Indian cities, nearly 33% of bus users in India prefer using website or a mobile app to access bus route and schedule information. Highlights from the survey also suggest that 44% in Bengaluru and Chennai, and 50% in Delhi use digital platforms to access bus-related information. All eight cities have transit apps, showing a strong mobile-first shift, though many still rely on offline sources.
- How do most Indian bus commuters get access to real-time information?
According to GIZ India and ITDP’s survey of eight Indian cities, for real-time information, 42% relied on apps, 10% on Google Maps, 16% on bus-stop displays, and a striking 32% had no real-time information at all. Nearly one in three riders was travelling blind, with no idea when their bus would arrive. However, live tracking was not available on all the routes captured on these apps, with some having only fixed schedules shown. On some apps, where live tracking was available, it wasn’t accurate.
- Why don’t all bus stops have real-time displays or clear schedules?
In India while bus agencies control fleets and operations, it is the Urban Local Bodies that maintain bus stops. This split means digital and physical upgrades often happen out of sync, leaving many stops with outdated or missing information.



















